'Swear to God, I 'll get to the Bali travelogues, but first, this...
Contrary to what many of my women blogging folk are feeling post-BlogHer conference, I have always and will forever more feel love and gratitude towards Heather Armstrong of that "wickedly funny blog", Dooce. Heather gave many of us, including me, permission to speak our truths publicly, particularly the truths about our depression, anxiety and how crazy-nutso-hard it is to parent young children. Anne Lamott's book "Operating Instructions" was revelatory and helpful in this regard, as well; any mother willing to call a spade a spade when it comes to the intrusion and anger she feels when her baby cries and can't stop is my sister. If she places that baby's incessant tears and wailing on the same level as Vietnam, as Anne Lamott accurately wrote, then she is my goddess for life for making the connection between that unrelenting war that could not be won and the colic that takes over the household for three straight months.
But, recently, the mainstream media has taken these goddesses up and over the proverbial shark jump. In the case of Anne Lamott, it was her awkward appearance on Stephen Colbert that put this much beloved author in a situation that she could not, even with all her charm and savvy, pull herself gracefully from. It was not a good environment for this author who gives raucous book readings and lectures so funny that I've seen folks rolling on the floor laughing. The Colbert Report studio audience did not warm to her, though Anne Lamott was able to slip in her description of Presbyterians as "God's frozen people" and the utterance of that one observation alone was worthy of a national audience.
For Heather Armstrong, her splendid blog Dooce has been diminished strictly as a money making machine, as glamorized by The New York Times and quite a few mainstream publications. Her powerful writing (not "content", WRITING, "content" is a crass marketing term that I hate with all my heart) is secondary to her blog ad generated income. This is a shame and not deserving of someone who has contributed greatly to the art of memoir and certainly to blogging (though not in a profound sense, as her husband Jon, in a misguided Bill Clinton-esque manner, credited Heather. In a recent post, Jon bestowed over-the-top entitlement to his wife in a blog entry that I will not link here but you can Google. This was not good for Heather as we recall what happened to Hillary with Bill's presence and big mouth on the campaign.). Dooce as money machine is boring and lifeless. Ironically, the daily field guide to capitalism, The Wall Street Journal, explored Heather's popularity as a writer/blogger and devoted just two paragraphs to her site's ad revenues.
Maybe both Anne Lamott and Heather Armstrong didn't so much as jump the shark, but, rather, jumped their niches. What is presented to the greater audience is not what they do best - pull us into their confidences and share their deepest pain and snarkiest observations in blog and book reading venues. We instead see them in packaged form, the money maker blogger, that lady writer who was on Colbert. It's like loving your excellent local indy band that makes the upward progression from the downtown club to the lineup in a festival then to back up a bigger band then to fame and fortune as headliners. And, once they hit headliner status, we lose our intimacy with them, they've "become commercial", they aren't as good as they used to be, they show up in the gossip columns slumming with Sienna Miller and Pete Doherty and, kiss of death, Amy Winehouse.
**************************
A related note on women's/mommy blogs:
What has been blatantly missing from the mainstream media coverage of the women's blogging community is the coup scored by a group of political bloggers who flaunt their mother status with pride. The mothers' group blog, MOMocrats, mommybloggers Pundit Mom and Queen of Spain have been granted much coveted and limited press credentials to cover the Democratic and Republican National Conventions.
The aforementioned New York Times article on Heather Armstrong/Dooce noted that "to the disappointment of some women who want sites that focus on serious issues like politics, advertisers are not interested in every kind of content.women’s/mother’s sites that cover 'serious issues' are getting their due." If this is true, this is very poor business acumen on the part of the advertisers who would behoove themselves to pay attention to "serious issues" blogs, the above blogs included. "Serious issues" are explored in a number of mainstream media publications sponsored by, guess who? Advertisers.
These women bloggers who were granted the invitations from the power brokers of the Democratic and Republican Committees to blog the conventions are now wielding incalcuable media clout and recognition. Next stop for these political mommy bloggers - White House press passes? Don’t be surprised if they score those, too.
PRESIDENT BUSH: Madam President, it is a pleasure to welcome you back
to the Oval Office. We have just had a very constructive dialogue.
First, I want to tell you how proud I am to be the President of a
nation that -- in which there's a lot of Philippine-Americans. They
love America and they love their heritage. And I reminded the President
that I am reminded of the great talent of the -- of our
Philippine-Americans when I eat dinner at the White House. (Laughter.)







Recent Comments